SO YOU WANT A RED LIP?
Personally, I use #4 Tarte Lipsurgence Matte in Fiery. It's the only lip color I presently own. I also tried at Sephora and liked #2 Nars Velvet matte Lip pencil in Cruella. The rest are a few more options I've heard people rave about.
1. Rimmel Kate Moss Matte lipstick #107 $4.99
2. Nars Velvet matte lip Pencil in Cruella
3. Nars Lipstick Jungle Red
4. Tarte Matte Lipsurgence in Fiery
5. Mac Ruby Woo
6. Revlon Really Red
7. Bite high pigment matte pencil Poppy
8. NYX matte Perfect red $5.99